Catfish Island
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Catfish Island Menu

Menu Catfish Island-1
Menu Catfish Island-1
Menu Catfish Island-2
Menu Catfish Island-2
Menu Catfish Island-3
Menu Catfish Island-3
Menu Catfish Island-4
Menu Catfish Island-4

Starters and Appetizers

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
$3.00
Mozzarella cheese sticks served with picante sauce or ranch for dipping
Fried Dill Pickle Spears
$3.00
fried dill pickle spears served with ranch for dipping
Cheddar Poppers
$3.00
jalapeño poppers filled with cheddar cheese
Fried Mushrooms
$3.00
fried mushrooms served with horseradish sauce or ranch for dipping
Peel And Eat Shrimp
$11.00
- peel and eat shrimp served with cocktail sauce for dipping
House Made Pork Skins
$6.00
In house made pork skins seasoned with strawberry barbecue seasoning
Jar Of Pickle Tomatoes
$8.00
Peanut Brittle
$6.00
patties of homemade peanut brittle

Catfish Dinners

Tiny Fisherman
$13.50
catfish fillets or steaks served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw and hush puppies
Little Fisherman
$14.50
catfish fillets or steaks served with fries or bake potato , coleslaw and hush puppies
Fisherman
$15.50
catfish fillets or steaks served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw and hush puppies
The Captain
$16.50
catfish fillets or steaks served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw and hush puppies
The Commander
$17.50
catfish fillets or steaks served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw and hush puppies
Extra Plate For Sharing
$3.00

Steaks

Fred Dad’s Special
$20.00
ounce ribeye, catfish fillets, popcorn shrimp served with coleslaw or salad and fries or a bake potato with a slice of Texas toast
Ribeye Steak
$17.00
ounce ribeye served with coleslaw or salad, and fries or bake potato and a slice of Texas toast
Steak And Shrimp
$19.00
ounce ribeye and fantail shrimp served with coleslaw or salad, and fries or bake potato with a slice of Texas toast
Hamburger Steak
$14.00
Hamburger steak with grilled onions served with coleslaw or salad, and fries or a bake potato with a slice of Texas toast
Ham Steak
$14.00
ounce ham steak served with coleslaw or salad, and fries or bake potato with a slice of Texas toast

Chicken Dinners

Piece Chicken Tenders
$13.50
chicken tenders served with coleslaw, fries or bake potato and hush puppies
Fish And Chicken
$15.00
catfish fillets and chicken tenders served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw and hushpuppies
BBQ Sauce
Sweet And Sour Sauce
House Made Ranch
Honey Mustard

Salads

Chef Salad
$11.00
Iceberg lettuce with onions, tomato, egg, pickle, croutons, bacon, shredded cheese and your choice of fried chicken, grilled chicken, or ham
Dinner Salad
$4.00
Iceberg lettuce with onions, tomato, croutons, and shredded cheese
Dressings
Ranch Italian Thousand Island Honey French Blue Cheese Honey mustard

The light side

Grilled Shrimp
$17.00
grilled shrimp seasoned with your choice of lemon pepper, Cajun or teriyaki with fries or bake potato, coleslaw or salad served on a bed of rice
Grilled Fish
$17.00
pieces of catfish fillets with your choice of lemon pepper or Cajun seasoning served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw or salad served on a bed of rice
Grilled Chicken Breast
$17.00
chicken breasts seasoned with your choice of lemon pepper or Cajun seasoning served with coleslaw or salad, fries or bake potato and Hushpuppies served on a bed of rice
Chicken Monterey
$17.00
grilled chicken breasts marinated in honey French dressing served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw or salad and Hushpuppies served on a bed of rice

Sugar Avenue Cakes

Caramel Cake
$6.00
slice of Caramel Cake
Chocolate Cake
$6.00
slice of Chocolate Cake
Banana Cake
$6.00
slice of Banana Cake
Pineapple Cake
$6.00
slice of Pineapple Cake
Coconut Cake
$6.00
slice of Coconut Cake
Strawberry Cake
$6.00
slice of Strawberry Cake
Lemon Cake
$6.00
slice of Lemon Cake

West Side Cakes

Carrot Cake
$6.00
slice of Carrot Cake

Letha’s Fried Pies

Peach Fried Pie
$4.00
Peach pie fried to a golden brown
Chocolate Fried Pie
$4.00
Chocolate cream pie fried to a golden brown
Coconut Fried Pie
$4.00
Coconut Cream pie fried to a golden brown
Apple Fried Pie
$4.00
Apple pie fried to a golden brown

Beverages

Pepsi
$3.50
Diet Pepsi
$3.50
Mountain Dew
$3.50
Fruit Punch
$3.50
Lemonade
$3.50
Dr Pepper
$3.50
Starry Lemon Lime Soda
$3.50
Water Bottle
$1.50
Coffee
$3.50
Sweet Tea
$3.50
Unsweet Tea
$3.50
Can Of Soda ( To Go Orders Only )
$1.50

Side Items

Hush Puppies
$1.00
Homemade Hushpuppies
Basket Of Fried Okra
$3.00
Breaded okra fried to a golden brown
Shredded Cheese
$1.00
Cup of shredded cheese
Bacon Bits
$1.00
Cup of bacon bits
French Fries
$3.00
Crinkle cut French fries
Bake Potato
$3.00
Small Coleslaw
$2.00
Large Coleslaw
$3.00
Green Pickled Tomatoes
$1.00
Catfish Fillet Or Catfish Steak
$3.00
Chicken Strip
$3.00
Onion Rings
$6.00
Beer battered onion rings
Cluster Of Crab Legs
$8.00
Cluster or Claw of snow crab legs
Bowl Of Beans With Hush Puppies
$3.00
Bowl of white or brown beans served with homemade Hushpuppies

Sandwiches

Hamburger
$9.50
All beef hamburger patty served on a toasted bun with lettuce, pickles, tomatoes, onions, mustard, mayonnaise & ketchup, served with fries or bake potato and coleslaw
Cheeseburger
$10.50
All beef patty served on a toasted bun with American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, onions, mustard, mayonnaise & ketchup, served with fries or bake potato & coleslaw
Fried Chicken Strip Sandwich
$9.50
Two fried chicken strips served on a toasted bun served with fries or bake potato & coleslaw
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$9.50
Grilled chicken breast served on a toasted bun served with fries or bake potato & coleslaw
Fried Catfish Sandwich
$9.50
catfish fillets served on a toasted bun served with fries or bake potato & coleslaw
Ham Sandwich
$9.50
Sliced ham served on Texas toast served with fries or bake potato & coleslaw

Child’s plates

Hamburger
$4.00
Cheeseburger
$5.00
Fish
$4.00
One piece of catfish fillet served with fries or bake potato
Chicken Tenders
$4.00
One chicken strip served with fries or bake potato
Popcorn Shrimp
$4.00
Popcorn shrimp served with fries or bake potato
Grilled Cheese
$5.00

Carry out specials

Catfish Net
$26.00
pc catfish fillets or steaks served with your choice of fries or bake potato, coleslaw & homemade Hushpuppies
Family Meal
$52.00
pc Catfish fillets or steaks , oz coleslaw , Hushpuppies & orders of fries or bake potatoes.

Seafood Plates

Seafood Platter
$17.00
catfish fillets or steaks , fantail shrimp, scallops, & stuffed crab served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw and Hushpuppies
Shrimp Platter
$17.00
large fantail shrimp served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw & Hushpuppies
Catfish & Frog Legs
$17.00
catfish fillets or steaks, frog legs, served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw & Hushpuppies
Stuffed Crab Platter
$13.00
stuffed crabs served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw & Hushpuppies
Frog Leg Platter
$17.00
Frog legs served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw & Hushpuppies
Scallop Platter
$17.00
breaded and fried scallops served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw & Hushpuppies
Crab Leg Platter
$25.00
pound of snow crab legs served with fries or bake potato, coleslaw & Hushpuppies

Catfish Island offers an enticing array of dishes that promise to satisfy every craving, whether you’re in the mood for a light bite or a hearty feast. As a review of their menu, here’s a closer look at what’s on offer:

Starting off with the Starters and Appetizers, the Mozzarella Cheese Sticks are a fan favorite—crispy on the outside with a melty, gooey center. If you’re in the mood for something a bit more tangy, the Fried Dill Pickle Spears are the perfect choice, offering a sharp contrast to the rich flavors of the Cheddar Poppers and Fried Mushrooms. The Peel And Eat Shrimp is another standout for those craving a seafood fix to kick off the meal.

For the main event, Catfish Dinners take center stage. Options like the Tiny Fisherman and Little Fisherman offer perfectly fried or grilled catfish portions for those with lighter appetites, while The Captain and The Commander serve up a more indulgent portion for the true seafood enthusiast.

If you prefer something from the Steaks section, the Fred Dad’s Special and Ribeye Steak are exceptional, cooked to perfection with tender juiciness. Pair them with a Steak and Shrimp combo for a surf-and-turf experience. Meanwhile, the Hamburger Steak and Ham Steak bring savory comfort food to the table.

For a lighter meal, the Grilled Shrimp, Grilled Fish, and Grilled Chicken Breast options are flavorful yet satisfying choices, along with the Chicken Monterey for a creamy twist.

End your meal on a sweet note with one of Catfish Island’s irresistible desserts, like the rich Caramel Cake, decadent Chocolate Cake, or tropical Pineapple Cake. If you’re craving a fried treat, their Fried Pies—ranging from Peach to Chocolate—offer the perfect balance of crunchy and sweet.

With a variety of sides like Hush Puppies, Basket of Fried Okra, and French Fries, there’s something for everyone, making Catfish Island a must-visit for any seafood lover or comfort food enthusiast.

Catfish Island

Catfish Island in Caldwell, AR offers delicious seafood dishes like catfish fillets and steaks served with all the fixings. Customers rave about the friendly staff and cozy atmosphere, making it a top choice for a satisfying meal.

Follow Us
  • facebook
  • Yelp
  • tripadvisor
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.